The Survey Brooklyn Technical High School Brooklyn, NY
Issue Date: Saturday, December 15, 2012 Issue: Spring 2013 Last Update: Sunday, February 10, 2013
Search

At-a-glance

Advertising

Music is a driving force in may individual’s lives. Thus, it is only probable that when faced with a scenario in which a free concert is at stake, people would do whatever it takes to win. Competitiveness is a universal behavior, but in no way does it excuse blatant disrespect towards others.

            Earlier in September, Brooklyn Tech participated in the Last School Standing contest hosted by 92.3 NOW. The grand prize featured a free concert in which former X-Factor contestant, Cher Lloyd, would perform. Throughout the competition, in a showdown of school pride, contestants responded to the events and to each other with unethical behavior and inappropriate retorts. These actions must not be tolerated, and all those concerned should be aware that their comments were unacceptable.

            Students from various districts across the nation were able to vote for their school once per computer, every hour. Brooklyn Tech made it to the top five in the finalist round, yet ended up coming in second to Freehold High School of Monmouth County in New Jersey. It seems that most of the hype concerning the contest was spread throughout social networking sites, like Facebook. Students, friends, and family, all contributed to spreading the news. The more people that were aware of the contest, the more votes a school could acquire.

            “I love her music, her sound, and just her in general. I really wanted a concert,” said Jacky Shao ’16.  

On the contrary, Afsara Tasnim ’16 said, “I’ve never actually heard any of her songs. I just voted in order for Tech to receive a free concert.”

            Marisa Cazanave, a music teacher, believes that music “most definitely” has the power to influence one’s actions. She says, “Throughout history, music has been used to rally people together and send out messages. These causes however, may be both positive and negative.” She also feels that “just like any reward system,” the promise of a free concert would vastly influence the way the public would behave. This seems to be apparent, as comments have been more negative according to how far behind, or ahead, the participating schools were.

            Throughout the entire challenge, there were a fair number of comments left in which people were trash talking each other. Upon looking through the comments section, one may notice that there are accusations of cheating, insults towards one another, and a vast use of profanity.

Many believe participants took the competition too far. Shao says that towards the final days, “people were so mean. A lot were targeting Freehold, calling them cheaters, and accusing them of using voting bots.” Voting bots are software programs used in order to perform automatic voting.

            Without a doubt, not many people are fans of losing. Therefore, when Tech placed as runner up, reactions varied. Some were upset, some shocked, and others just glad it was all over. It seems throughout the competition, school pride became the reason for voting, and not the music itself. The competition was no longer about music. It became a battle over which school was better.

“Half the people in our school don’t even know who Cher Lloyd is. Plus, freshmen who aren’t fourteen yet wouldn’t even be able to attend. If we won, people would go to the concert to be with friends, not for the music,” says Tasnim.

            A performer, no matter how popular, is not worth the conduct shown by some individuals. Students need to realize that no matter what the circumstances are, misconduct isn’t appropriate. A better solution would be to eliminate the popularity of such comments in the first place.

Freedom of speech is a right that should be practiced, but not to the point where insults are being thrown around. The few people who did succumb to such unethical behaviors give a distorted image of the participating schools.

            Cazanave says, “I don’t think anyone is worth all the disrespect shown. People are entitled to their own opinions. If they were proven wrong, they should accept the fact and keep silent.”

Back to the articles list

5 COMMENTS - Add your comment below

11/17/2012 10:24:42 PM by Yong Hao Song    
I also voted in the contest. When I was on the voting page, I did remember some people "Trolling" and verbally attacking other schools. I do agree that it is unnecessary and immature to anonymously try to piss off a group of strangers, but I also think people should be able to say what they want.
11/16/2012 11:14:48 PM by Hesham Abdalla    
I was one of the people that participated in this showdown and this wasn't your average contest. It was war. New York vs. New Jersey. Freehold vs. Tech. Every time a school beat down the other the hate messages grew. If you scrolled down the comments under the poll, you can see the massive amounts of "trolls" and accusations made of using "bots" and unfair tactics. Overall, I feel this article portrays what happened and gives you an in depth background of what happened. However, the main driving force was the class of 2013, so asking the class of 2016 really doesn't give you that "feel" of emotions that were high during this contest. It was devastating when we lost to Freehold because we worked very hard day and night spreading the news. I remember when everyone got angry that Freehold entered this contest even though they weren't allowed to hold concerts. We were crossing our fingers hoping that this concert would go to us, but it was to no avail. To me, it doesn't matter about the loss. We showed the Tri State area how powerful and well knit community Tech is and we have that spirit to win. Even though we didn't get the concert, we still have many opportunities to celebrate a wonderful senior year at Tech!!
11/16/2012 10:44:49 PM by Mandeep Kaur    
The first thing I actually noticed about this contest was the trash-talking. My friend was really motivated to win and tried to get everyone to vote every hour, and I could tell her competitive side was getting the best of her. One of the main reasons behind that, in my opinion, was the fact that the contest started off with everyone insulting each other on the 92.3 page. Some students accusing each other of cheating, some making racist remarks, and some just completely off topic with the contest. It was definitely unnecessary and uncalled for. On a different note, I believe that Tech students, even when not knowing who Cher Lloyd was, really wanted this concert to just get a break from the work and have an unforgettable memory. And that is the good side to the competitiveness; the unity the students develop when trying to accomplish one goal.
11/16/2012 2:23:32 AM by Gerena Tan    
I actually voted in that contest myself and I have to agree with you, some of those comments were pretty vicious. Honestly, people tend to get over-competitive. There were also a lot of people "trolling" in the comment section that just went about pissing everyone off like that whitepowernj guy. There was also a whitepowerny but I'm not sure if it was the same person. They just kept posting racist things. Whitepowernj bashed on Asians a lot (small eyes, eats dogs, etc). One suggestion I have would be for you to interview a variety of students and not just those in the class of 2016. You also added an extra "o" in losing in your title and forgot an "n" in many in your first sentence. It's important to carefully proofread your article, especially your title and first sentence since it's what people look at first!
11/16/2012 2:18:06 AM by June    
This contest was basically a competition to see how much a school can motivate its students into winning a contest. Though we may have lost, it just gives us a sense of how unified this school really is compared to other schools. Tech is known to be one of the largest high schools in the city yet we couldn't win against a high school from another state, this just shows how much students in this school really care about these sorts of things. We might take this lost to the heart but we must remember there will be other contests to prove ourselves as a united school. Therefore this article hits a good point, if you have nothing nice to say it is best not to mention it at all.
ADD YOUR COMMENT
Name
Email
Comments, recommendations or suggestions.
Submit

Staff View

Hazel Millard

Editor in Chief
Email Me

Artem

Managing Editor
Email Me

Carol

Layout Editor
Email Me

AllexD

Arts & Entertainment Editor
Email Me

celine

Copy Editor of Arts and Entertainment
Email Me

kmach

Photography Editor
Email Me

Nikita Dubnov

Mr.
Email Me

Kenny Garner


Email Me

aschierenbeck

News Editor
Email Me

Nicole Bagnarol

Editorials Co-Editor
Email Me

Isabella Divilova

Editorials Co-Editor
Email Me

jgibbel

Layout Editor
Email Me

Geoffrey Greene

Features Editor
Email Me

wmuflahi

Features Copy Editor
Email Me

Savannah Pees

Hard News Copy Editor
Email Me

Online Archives

There are currently 9 editions on-line. Click on edition name to view articles.

Current Conditions Cloudy
Temperature: 57.5 °F
Wind Speed: 3 mph S
Gusts: 11 mph S
Rain Today: 0 "

View PDF's

Advertising