"We
have nothing to learn from education in Third World countries, much
less a Third World country that lacks freedom of speech," said a
professor at the Harvard Graduate School of Education, according to
www.2mminutes.com. Many
other Americans, however, dispute this statement. They would avouch
that, yes, America does have quite a lot to learn from Third World
countries.
"What is now surprising and worrisome is U.S. students are even lagging the developing world, " Bill Compton said on www.2mminutes. "If
our athletic performance at the Olympics were as poor as our global
academic performance, it would be a national crisis and every level of
government would be attempting to respond. That we blithely ignore the
declining intellectual standards of American students seems almost
insane. The cognitive skills of our children will determine both
America's economic future and the economic future of each child."
A documentary movie called "Two million Minutes" was created to compare
and contrast schools in different parts of the world. The movie stated
that America places 24th out of 29 countries that are proficient in
mathematics by the 12th grade.
Junior Egalita Irfan said,"Honestly,
schools in USA are much easier, if you ask me. First, you can choose
classes you want to take, so you don't have to take classes that you
are not good at."
Irfan is an exchange student from Indonesia who came here three months
ago and is living with an American family. In Indonesia, Irfan wore a
uniform to school and did not switch classes. She stayed in the same
classroom, and the only thing that changed were the teachers, who
switched classes.
"We
have the same students in the same class for a year, and we change
classes and classmates every year. We can't choose classes we're
taking," Irfan said. "In Indonesian high school, you can only choose
two major classes: science class or social studies class. In science class, you have to take all the science subjects: chemistry, physics and biology. You have to. You can not choose. And in social studies class you have to take history, sociology and geography. And for both classes, math, Indonesian Government,
Indonesian Language, Physical Education and English are required," she
said.
Some countries even go to school earlier in the day than the United
States. For example, Irfan had to go to school every day Monday through
Friday at 6:30 a.m. The end of the school day varies due to extra curricular
programs or tutoring.
Another difference Irfan pointed out is the attitudes students have toward their teachers.
"Some attitudes of the students that is categorized as 'fine' here can be considered 'impolite' in Indonesia," Irfan said.
Many American students sleep in class and do not do much homework.
Procrastination is a major conundrum when it comes to doing work. "Two
Million Minutes" said eight out of 10 students would preferably go to
football games, to the movies and just hang out with friends than work
on their project due the following day of school.
"I like both schools, here and Indonesia. It's just different. I can
learn so many things in a year in my school in Indonesia, but my school
there sometimes makes me crazy if my brain is burdened too much," Irfan
joked. "And it's fun here. I can choose my own class and I don't
really have to use my brain on those classes, except when I'm stuck
with language. I can use a calculator here, too, so I think I lose some
of my manual calculating ability!"