The Spartan Chronicles Campbell High School Smyrna, GA
Issue Date: Friday, January 18, 2013 Issue: 2 Spring 2013 Last Update: Monday, April 29, 2013

Read our blogs .....

View More

Advertising
Congratulations to Coach Gwyn for his 400th win!

At-a-glance

"If I Were A Poor Black Kid"...EXCUSE ME?
Courtney Britton - Courtney Britton
Advertising

If I were a well-off middle aged white man, I wouldn’t be writing columns about if I were a poor black kid.

Recently, Gene Marks, a contributor to Forbes magazine wrote an article called “If I Were A Poor Black Kid” explaining helpful tips to overcome the plague of poverty.  Marks writes with explicit detail about how he would use internet resources such as SparkNotes, CliffsNotes and Google to help him understand books providing his fantasized black kid’s parents could afford a computer and high speed internet. Marks “helpfully” includes other websites and other tools to help the poor black children understand what they are learning.

Excuse me?

The last time I checked, common sense doesn’t discriminate against races. Any teen or kid can use the resources Marks listed and I’m sure many of them do. It’s logical to ask for help when you need it – pride may get in the way during adolescent to adult years, but as a kid, one’s brain is like a sponge. It craves information and soaks it up. It’s not all about Facebook, Twitter, or YouTube. Some of us actually like to read.

Yes, private and magnet schools can be better than public schools because they offer more resources, but you don’t need them to succeed in life. It takes hard work, determination and an awareness of class and race. My nana once told me, “Nothing in life is free. You have to work for what you want; nothing in life is just handed to you.” While this is true, it’s harder for poor black kids in America, despite their hard work and effort.

Even if a poor black kid’s parents could afford this cheap technology of which Marks speaks so highly, what’s next? Is the computer supposed to save them from stray bullets? Is it supposed to feed them? I guess if they had this computer, they could use it to do their homework. And what if mommy/daddy/ grandparents/guardian can’t pay the electric bill that month? Then what? How are you supposed to do your homework then? I guess Marks expects these poor black kids to light some candles (providing they have money for them) or better yet, use the street lights.

Born and raised in a black, single parent household, I find this article highly offensive. I went to the private schools he praises in this column, from kindergarten to second grade. At my private, mainly white, Catholic school at the tender age of five, I realized that what grades I made didn’t matter and my personality didn’t matter. Even the fact that I was one of the smartest in my class didn’t matter. None of it did – I would never be as good as my fellow white students, simply because I was black. And those little precious four, five, and six year olds reminded me every chance they got.

My mom did my hair in twists every morning. When I got to school the white girls in my class would play with their hair and swing it right in front of my face. So I figured, why couldn’t I? I would take out the twists and re-twist them…I just wanted to fit in at this age. But it wasn’t the same, and those girls let me know it. And to top it off, the third day I did, I got a note sent home to my mother, asking her not to do my hair in those styles anymore because I played with it during class. I was teased from everything to what my hair looked like to what I carried my lunch in, and when I tried to ignore it, like my mom told me to, my teacher sent another note home saying I didn’t play well with others. I knew then that I was truly by myself; my teacher was NOT on my side. Needless to say, my mom withdrew me before the third grade.

To think that columnist Marks can just assume he knows, or imagines to know, what it feels like to be black, and to be a poor black kid at that is ridiculous. You can’t just place a poor black kid in a better school and expect him or her to succeed. Some kids will feel more out of place than ever, and with no one to confide in, may turn to the streets.

Oh wait, if they have a computer and internet access at home, they’ll be fine.

 


Back to the articles list

6 COMMENTS - Add your comment below

1/2/2012 1:40:31 PM by victoria canning    
good job courtney! well written , you hit the importance in this article.
12/21/2011 8:07:17 PM by Denisha Bell    
This is really good Courtney! Your points were valid and it kept my attention! Very well written.
12/20/2011 9:14:27 AM by Betsy Bunte    
Courtney, your article reflects a thoughtful, personal response to a troubling situation. Well-written! I hope that teachers at Campbell are sensitive to the issues you raise. Strong faculty members like (above) Ms. Braxton and Coach McClure "set the bar high" for others.
12/20/2011 8:12:40 AM by Skyla Hutchins    
Great job Courtney!!! Having been raised in public housing and in a single parent home, I KNOW exactly how you feel... because I feel the same.
12/20/2011 7:17:41 AM by Marisa Braxton    
Great job Courtney! Your response to Mr. Marks article addressed the assumptions that often plagued so many of our students today, but especially the students he tried to "understand". Thanks to your comments many teachers and other critics who want to offer help but may not realize they are perpetuating a stereotype will be better informed.
12/19/2011 10:38:17 PM by Randy McClure    
Courtney has truly captured the experience and expressed the sentiments of the knowledgeable student in the experience that Marks speaks of hypothetically . The uninformed opinion and supposed responses to situations that some would love to share with us many times is not valid and this time the author was "called" on it by one of those he purports to speak for. Great job Courtney!
ADD YOUR COMMENT
Name
Email
Comments, recommendations or suggestions.
Submit

Spartan Chronicles Staff

Lucas Mollet

Editor In Chief
Email Me

Charles R.

Managing Editor/Business Editor
Email Me

Ryan Hiles

News Editor
Email Me

Emmanuel

Opinions Editor
Email Me

Devin Fraction

Features Editor
Email Me

aleah prather

Entertainment Editor
Email Me

Marjorie Benson

Entertainment Editor
Email Me

Shari Huggins

Reporter
Email Me

Isaias Calderon

Reporter
Email Me

anahipoxleitner

Reporter
Email Me

Mikayla Lee

Reporter
Email Me

Dasia Woodson

Reporter
Email Me

j.l.ridgley

Reporter
Email Me

Mikayla Lee

Reporter
Email Me

Kevin Van

Reporter
Email Me

Chance Jones

Reporter
Email Me

Kartiayla Beach

Reporter
Email Me

Maya Nicholson

Freelancer
Email Me

Leo Lopez


Email Me

Cierra Coleman

Reporter
Email Me

Liliana Medrano


Email Me

AnalyOstos

Reporter
Email Me

Ashli Mitchell

Reporter
Email Me

Lily Alvarado


Email Me

Khalia Hailey

Reporter
Email Me

Tandra Smith


Email Me

Tanayja Black

Reporter
Email Me

Ms. Deborah.Aughey, NBCT

Adviser
Email Me

Mitraa

Reporter
Email Me

Tatum Ynclino

Reporter
Email Me

Shama Patel

Reporter
Email Me

nayomiohouo


Email Me

Kayla Jones


Email Me

PDFs

Previous Editions

There are currently 35 editions on-line. Click on edition name to view articles.

Search
Current Conditions Rain Showers
Temperature: 73.2 °F
Wind Speed: 0 mph SW
Gusts: 5 mph W
Rain Today: N/A "