A survey of 50 middle school students at T.H. Rogers. - Camila Peterson
It is required by the state of Texas for middle schoolers to
take TPSP, or the Texas Performance Standards Project. The tasks reflect
independent work, research, and solutions of individual students on their
topics, whether it be creating a business, writing a story to send to a
publishing company, or writing a research journal on a recent medical
breakthrough. It is designed to generate a sense of excitement for learning new
information and exploring various careers. The tasks are quite open minded and
house minimal limitations. Students are encouraged to show their full potential
of creativity, and unlike science fair and history fair, these projects are not
judged and given prizes, which can discourage people and lower their self
esteem.
In addition to demonstrating your full potential, TPSP is
also designed to enhance your research skills, preparing you for high school
and college. Students must gather all their information and research to create
a final product, one that reflects their immense efforts, and they will deliver
a 15-20 minute presentation to their mentor, while other students are welcome
to come and observe. According to the middle school Art/Art1 teacher, Ms. Tata,
TPSP is worthwhile, but “a little obtuse.” Ms. Tata was asked if the
‘positives’ of TPSP outweigh the ‘negatives.’ She responded, “It’s the first
year the guidelines aren’t very specific, and usually teachers want to monitor
grades, but this leaves it all to you. In theory, it’s really great; we should
have started this earlier.”
However, from another point of view, TPSP is an unnecessary
waste of time that is completely uncalled for. Several people are questioning
the reasoning behind TPSP, and are arguing that this project commences a great
deal of time and effort, diverting attention from studying for tests, or
completing major assignments that are actually being GRADED, unlike TPSP. Is
TPSP really a waste of time? Would most students rather continue with science
fair or history fair? Why is it that the state of Texas has REQUIRED students
to do TPSP this year? Why were last year’s students not required to do
it?
Give us your feedback at kanyeskorner@gmail.com.