Search
The Californian California High School San Ramon, CA
Issue Date: Thursday, May 21, 2009 Issue: Volume XVIII, Issue VII Last Update: Tuesday, June 09, 2009
Current Conditions Mostly Sunny
Temperature: 54.4 °F
Wind Speed: 8 mph WSW
Gusts: 25 mph W
Rain Today: 0 "

At-a-glance

Milk moves audiences with Penn's performance
Milk, starring Sean Penn, is about a homosexual politician who was elected to San Francisco's Board of Supervisors and was murdered. - esquire.com
Advertising

“Milk” – the new Gus Van Sant biopic about the first openlygay man to be elected to office – shines as brightly as the man it portrays,San Francisco City Supervisor Harvey Milk.

The film follows the story of Milk, played by Sean Penn, from1972 to 1978, the year he was assassinated by former Supervisor Dan White (JoshBrolin).

The movie revolves around Milk’s personal life, politicalascendancy and ultimate legacy. Portrayed beautifully through an interweaving of archival footage,re-enactments and delicate scenes of a prophetic Milk sitting at a kitchentable recording his will.

The story begins in New York City, where Milk and Scott Smith(James Franco) meet and fall in love. The couple then moves to San Francisco and opens a camera store, CastroCamera.  The store becomes ahangout among residents and later, Milk’s campaign headquarters.

Milk meets Cleve Jones (Emile Hirsch), a young activist whopersuades him to run for public office. Milk’s political ambitions slightly take over his life and put a strainon his relationship with Smith. After three consecutive losses, Smith leaves him.  In 1978, Milk is elected to the boardof supervisors with the help of a new campaign manager, Anne Kronenberg (AlisonPill).

During this time, Milk takes on a doomed relationship withJack Lira (Diego Luna).  He alsobefriends White and Mayor George Moscone (Victor Garber).  Milk leads a powerful fight for gayrights and defeats Proposition 6, also known as the Briggs Initiative, whichbanned gays from working in California’s public schools.  It was sponsored by conservative statelegislator John Briggs and singer Anita Bryant.

White, fighting with his own demons and upset by Milk’sactions, resigns and is turned down when he tries to get re-appointed.  Feeling betrayed, he assassinates bothMoscone and Milk on November 26, 1978 at City Hall.

Brolin’s performance, which provides incredible insight tosuch a complex character, cannot be forgotten.  With almost childlike frustration, he reveals White’s inner torment.  And while White’s actions can never berationalized, Brolin gave him a desperateness that almost makes us feel bad forhim.

Franco made Smith a very admirable character.  He gives Smith a perfect combination ofquiet strength and shyness.  Franco’sfriendly face only increased Smith’s precedent likability.  Watching him on screen can only makeviewers smile.

A very shy and witty Hirsch has some unforgettable moments aswell. Whether he was rallying a crowd or waltzing with Pil, it was hard not to beenchanted by him.

Although all the actors aced their performances, “Milk”really belongs to Penn, whose inspiring and endearing portrayal of Milk wasincendiary.  He was so in tune withhis character, one doesn’t even see Pen the actor.  He is Harvey Milk. He is spot on, and undoubtedly has no trouble capturing many heartsduring his delivery of Milk’s “Hope Speech.”

Van Sant made the story of Harvey Milk unforgettable.  It is powerful, smart, funny,thought-provoking, heartbreaking, and tear-inducingly inspiring.  It could not have come at a bettertime.

It is one of the best films of the year.

 


Back to the articles list

5 COMMENTS - Add your comment below

1/11/2009 12:55:30 AM by Zhuchen Xu    
I actually just watched a documentary on Harvey Milk on Hulu. This review is exceptionally well written (props to Chelsie!) and really gives life to the characters. I'm extremely glad that this review shows how well the characters and the events were acted out rather than summarizing the plot. Great job!
1/10/2009 11:48:42 PM by Anca Ulea    
This story was really eloquently written. Good job Chelsie. :) I keep trying to go see that movie but it never works out...
1/8/2009 12:46:54 AM by Han-Joo Kim    
I love this story too. In fact, if stories were people, this story would be my wife number two, right next to the Twilight story. Only, I might not be able to get married with it, because gay marriage isn't legal and Milk is a male movie.... Oh well, DOWN WITH THE ESTABLISHMENT
1/7/2009 7:28:11 PM by Austin    
This article made me want to watch the movie. It was really professional and well written.
1/7/2009 6:30:54 PM by Bridget :)    
Hey Chelsie! I really liked your insight on the movie Milk. I can see that you really loved this character and Sean Penn who played them. My only critique would be to maybe find some flaws. It wasn't that perfect, was it?
ADD YOUR COMMENT
Name
Email
Comments, recommendations or suggestions.
Submit

Staff View

Zhuchen Xu

Editor in Chief

Jordan Hung

Managing Editor

Jean Zhu

Photo Editor

Rachel Cox

Business Manager

Bridget Bugbee

News Editor

Peggah Elahi

News Editor

Maiah Hollander

News Editor

Shilpa Balaji

Features Editor

Justin Jozwiak

Features Editor

Danielle Fernandez

Sports Editor

Trey Nelson

Sports Editor

Jason Alpert

Sports Editor

Shankar Logarajah

Entertainment Editor

Kyle Teese

Entertainment Editor

Abhinay Gajjala

Opinions Editor

John Isom

Opinions Editor

Max Feldman

News Lite Editor

Bailey Meyers

Copy Editor

Samara Al-Jumaily

Staff Writer

Aaron Bandler

Staff Writer

Staci Barranti

Staff Writer

Kelsey Belomy

Staff Writer

Austin Brooks

Staff Writer

Chelsie Chan

Staff Writer

Carly Chiesa

Staff Writer

Katrina Curry

Staff Writer

Ramsey DeLano

Staff Writer

Rachel Dittman

Staff Writer

Brandon Eiges

Staff Writer

Maithili Jalihal

Staff Writer

Ashley Jensen

Staff Writer

Han-Joo Kim

Staff Writer

Steven Lau

Staff Writer

Priscilla Lee

Staff Writer

Griffin Lewis

Staff Writer

Colleen Lillig

Staff Writer

Anthony Mignano

Staff Writer

Megan Molina

Staff Writer

Brett Morris

Staff Writer

Anshil Popli

Staff Writer

Sadie Remington

Staff Writer

Sana Sareshwala

Staff Writer

Meena Tafazzoli

Staff Writer

Anca Ulea

Staff Writer

Chloe Uyehara

Staff Writer

Clayton Wenner

Staff Writer

Nicola Yap

Staff Writer

Dennis Yim

Staff Writer

Cady DeLano

Photographer

Jake Sigl

Photographer

Sachin Patel

Photographer

Matt Pinto

Photographer

Dylan Booth

Graphics

Carlo Miraflor

Graphics

Brian Barr

Advisor
Email Me

Online Archives

There are currently 23 editions on-line. Click on edition name to view articles.

Advertising